Tuesday, October 6, 2015

A survey you can try

Anyone who is curious about the trends in Book of Mormon geography can ask their LDS friends a simple question:

Mesoamerica or North America?

If you get any Mesoamerican believers, follow up with:

Do you think the Book of Mormon Cumorah was in New York or southern Mexico?

If they say Mexico, you'll be tempted to ask what they think of Oliver Cowdery and David Whitmer, but I recommend against starting a discussion about it. This is a survey. Just see what people think.

Of course, if they want to discuss it, you know what to say.

_________________

So far, I've never met anyone who thinks Cumorah was in Mexico, apart from those who write for FARMS/Maxwell Institute, BMAF, and FairMormon and a few people who believe what those writers claim. Most people accept what Oliver Cowdery and every other contemporary of Joseph Smith did; i.e., that there is one Cumorah and it's in New York.

2 comments:

  1. Actually, my experience had been that the vast majority of Latter-day Saints have never thought or read about the matter, and reason they believe the drumlin in New York is the Cumorah of the Book of Mormon is that is the conventional understanding. Oliver Cowdery's personal belief never enters into it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Actually, my experience had been that the vast majority of Latter-day Saints have never thought or read about the matter, and reason they believe the drumlin in New York is the Cumorah of the Book of Mormon is that is the conventional understanding. Oliver Cowdery's personal belief never enters into it.

    ReplyDelete